literature

December Book Drop

So You Want To Talk About Race

By: Ijeoma Oluo

This is one of many books that falls under the intersection of self-help and sociology. As a cis-het white woman, its a genre I come back to again and again. Having read and heavily recommended The New Jim Crow, I want to circle back to those of you who took that rec. I had feedback from some saying it was good but they themselves felt a little affronted as the reader like they were being personally called out, unfairly so. I had others who thought the books was great and passed it on to people who had that same feedback. This kind of book can definitely be uncomfortable for the white reader and the more status quo conforming readers out there. Like anything, there is a bit of a learning curve. Its ok to have feelings, to recognize and examine them. Some books are way more challenging to that end than others. I think The New Jim Crow really requires either the timing to be exactly perfect that the reader is ready to be challenged OR that the person has already moved past that point and is comfortable with being challenged already.

All of this is set up to say, Ijeoma Oluo covers some of the same territory and also explores other territories. She takes a more personal approach. She takes a more story-telling approach. The combination of which makes this relatable, insightful, funny, and heart-breaking all in one. If you or someone you know wanted to read The New Jim Crow and found yourself wanting to push back a lot on your emotions I would recommend circling back to it later and instead start here.

The Warrior’s Apprentice

By: Lois McMaster Bujold

Ok this was great. This series continues to be a favorite T-Shirt, a refreshing beverage, a shady respite on a hot day. It’s rather epic, with the total number of books in the double digits. A handful in and the characters and dialog continue to be delightful and engaging. This is the kind of series you can enjoy without being so thoroughly engrossed as to lose sight of everything else. I appreciate that. As with the other books in the series I’ve read, there is a very gradual ramp up in this novel. The stakes got high but I never felt emotionally drained as I do with some of my more favorite books. That, to me, is a good thing. Not every book I read can be gripping or the best book I’ve ever read. But similarly going from mountains highs of literature to the dregs is also not enjoyable. This series has allowed the come down from The Red Rising to be gradual. They stand alone as enjoyable writing. Miles Vorkosigan is a very fun main. In The Warrior’s Apprentice we have entered into his story-line and things are already interesting but I have a feeling the best is yet to come.

The Poetic Edda

By: Jackson Crawford

This is my second tango with The Poetic Edda. I listened to the book - narrated by the author. It was harder to follow but worthwhile. Its nice to hear the names pronounced by a scholar of the language. Additionally, something as personal as The Cowboy Edda included as an afterword are best shared directly. It was this final personal interpretation/extrapolation by the author that inspired me to look him up. A few takeaways from so-doing…

1. Apparently he is THE man when it comes to ancient Norse runes and pronunciation. So that’s cool and made me feel even better about listening/reading.

2. Jackson Crawford just gives me James Holden from The Expanse vibes but like slightly more a for-real cowboy. Probably someone I’d invite to my backyard bbq.

Anyway, I look forward to circling back for a re-read, also to moving on the The Prose Edda and finally to reading The Saga of The Volsungs next…got study up on my Obsidian lore IYKYK.

A Monster Like Me

By: Wendy S. Swore

This is a middle reader book so I chose it for Vor and me. I waffled for quite some time before deciding to queue it up and even afterwards I curated others ahead. I thought it would be good but possible a bit too heavy for Vor. I think maturity-wise he ended up being on the right side of being able to comprehend the larger message of the story. The actual writing was great. The first person perspective was fresh and enjoyable for a kid’s book and the imagery was very well done. Vor and I were both able to have pretty vivid ideas in our head of what was going on.

Definitely recommend. Being as the main character is a child, I doubt most adults reading for pleasure would want to engage. For those with kids, you will have to gauge your own child’s ability to handle a story that features bullying, medical issues, and possible mental health issues. Is there resolution? Yes. So if that is something you need, don’t feel afeared.

The Hidden Nazi

By: Dean Reuter

I read this book because the subject matter was interesting to me. I knew Dean Reuter was a familiar name to me but I didn’t know how. You know a person is powerful when they lead a very public life yet they have been able to stifle Wiki from having an article about them. Ironically, the only information on the internet about Dean Reuters is the information he wants you to see. The hypocrisy is not lost on me.

This book, was, nonetheless fascinating. DR is the first named author but sounds like Lowery and Chester were the real driving forces being this book being written. I found myself, several times, going into deep dives to find info and pictures of players in the Nazi regime that I hadn’t heard of or had only heard of in passing. The reason is, it was really really hard for me to wrap my head around these men being “family men” at home with their wive and children then going to do what they did. I felt compelled to try to put a face with the name - to see them as humans who actively made the decisions that led to their places in history.

I learned a lot by reading this book. There were moments when horrific actions were outlined but the book was tasteful in how sparingly they were used. While the book follows the trail of Hans Kammler, it is maybe more about the organization of the Nazi party and how people were able to move through the ranks, how various large-scale programs and operations were able to be enacted, and ultimately about the V2 bomb program and infrastructure. A grim but fascinating read.

Paddle-to-the-Sea

By: Holling Clancy Holling

I wanted Vor to read this for the nostalgia factor it brings me. I read this when I was growing up and lived in Michigan. He and I both really enjoyed it. Alert to parents - language re: Indigenous People of Canada. I think this book is to be utterly respectful to the culture of the young Canadian Indigenous boy who constructs Paddle-to-the-Sea and sets the figurine on its way. The reality is the book was written in the 60’s and language did not reflect the intention. This is a good opportunity to talk about such things with your kid. I think it is otherwise fine. Feel free to share any differing opinions or support for or against mine with sources in the comments so people can self-educate.

Implied Spaces

By: Walter Jon Williams

Perhaps I expect everything to suck. I mean, I only choose to read books above a certain threshold of positive reviews. But part of me is still expecting that won’t matter and what I choose to read is going to underwhelm me. Thankfully, Implied Spaces was more enjoyable than I expected it to be. It was a hodgepodge monstrosity of genres mashing up but it was still fun imo. I thought the science was good and played into the story enjoyably while softening at its edges just enough to allow for words like Zombie to be thrown around plausibly. Additional marks given for treating gender as a fluid concept and for having a super-computer sentience housed in a black cat.

Trapped in the Overworld

By: Winter Morgan

Back to the world of Minecraft. Winter Morgan knows how to stay in their lane. I like that about them. I thought the other series Vor and I read about Steve and his sword were better. But, this was still enjoyable as far as Minecraft adventure novels go. Do a bunch of kids get trapped in Minecraft? Yes. Hordes and mobs ensue. If you’ve read one you’ve read them all. If your kid likes Minecraft, quality isn’t a factor. Thankfully, Vor is not obsessed. And the kid is partaking of high-level literature left right and center so I feel obligated to lob him one on occasion. This series is that. My advice - never give them Minecraft to begin with. I joke. But I do think there are other series that are bette than this one. From the vantage point of having finished them all, they weren’t as exciting.

Leviathan Falls

By: James S.A. Corey

I will probably re-read The Expanse 20 more times before I die. Much like with Red Rising, these are not fictional characters to me. They are besties. They provide as much comfort to me as the flesh and blood humans I walk with, skate with, surf with, etc. That being said, this is my least favorite book of the series. I have thus far stayed away from star ratings but to give a feel - probably a 3.5 or 4 compared to the others all being 4.5 or 5 star books. Essentially, my gripes rest on a lack of willingness to break out of the mold for the final book. The “mold” is fine when you are expanding the scope but when its time to wrap it up, bold action/writing is required to pull the scope back in and get down to what this was all about.

Light spoiler - while the universe is burning down around them, humans get distracted by petty bullshit. To me, instead of trying and possibly failing to explain the speculative science behind the beings that killed the gate-builders, the writing team focused, instead, on interpersonal shit between the Roci crew and the main antagonist. I did end up liking her comeuppance, however. Jim finished up in heart-wrenchingly predictable fashion. I could have done with double the amount of Teresa’s perspective. Similarly, I wanted to learn more about the gate-builders through Elvi.

In the end, it felt like there was a good bit of playing the story safe. BUT that is totally speculation on my part. Had anything changed the ending could have sucked. Suck it did not. It just didn’t blow my mind to the level I was hoping it would. There I go having expectations. lol!

The Republican Brain

By: Chris Mooney

He said what he said. This is old news, but in case you didn’t know. Nothing short of a life-altering event is likely to change someone’s mind about their political affiliations or their “beliefs.” This book goes into the “why” behind that phenomenon. Does this book spend time on failures of the Democratic Brain as well? Yes. But its also not the central theme of the book.

I had to read this book when it I felt like I could take it in and not be depressed by it. Many of my older family members are Republicans and fall into the predictable patterns discussed in this book. In review, this makes me have a sad. I honestly, truly, think the world would be better off without corporate Christianity and capitalism. Those two things go relatively hand in hand with American-bred Republicanism. This book covers a little of that common ground but largely sticks to social trends, examples of Republicans through time adhering to weird denials of science and reality, sociological studies, and psychological studies that support the titular statement.

Its not a total lambast. Credit and positive attributes of Republicans are noted throughout but the author and yt don’t think that a few good traits make up for the headaches and problems that arise when a huge segment of society is nearly incapable of wrapping their heads around science and its implications.

Mobs in the Mine

By: Winter Morgan

The first book in the series was better than this one. Whereas the first book establishes the characters and overall tension of the series, this book establishes what is to become a trope. I am going to refrain from telling you what it is, imo. The reason being, if you or your kids are into Minecraft you’re not going to care. If you’re not and you read it anyway…well that was your choice and you just have to know that these books are basic and repetitive. Sure there’s a bigger story arc being played out. But ultimately, Winter Morgan is exploring different ways to highlight fan-favorite features of the Minecraft world and the story functions as a means to that end more than to tell the story itself. You read these because you like Minecraft not because you want a good story.

November Book Drop

Lo, friends! Tis almost the end of the year. I almost cannot believe it. I have two more of these reviews to go before we are into 2022. Next month I will do a Top Ten List in addition to the normal review. As of the time of this entry, I am 120 books into the year. Hopefully I can keep up this pace next year too! I managed 12 books this month to make up for the last couple of months of slacking ;-)

God Emperor of Dune

By: Frank Herbert

I still love this book. I’ve read through the series five times and I still love this book. I am more critical of it than ever and I still love it. Its dense. Leto can be pompous. The Duncans can be obtuse. Nonetheless, the philosophical through-line is very clear and rings true even after so many years. It is an odd masterpiece. It sticks out like a sore thumb in the series as a whole, but it’s really great. Related aside: I run a Dune Stan account on Instagram. www.instagram.com/dunequotes I’m the OG Dune Quotes page on Insta since 2016. If you want to cheat and get some quote samplage, check it out. If you like what you see there, you’ll like the books.

The Golden Goblet

By: Eloise Jarvis McGraw

This was a mom-and-me read. It took a little while for Vor to get into it. I had to stop and give context quite a lot in the beginning. The first two thirds of the book were rather slow. There was a lot of repetition and a lot of setup for the ultimate resolution. However, the resolution felt very rushed and lacking in detail especially when compared to the rest of the book. I think it was worth a read but I’m glad we did it on our own terms. I think if I were one of the many kids that are forced to read this in school I would have resented the hell out of the ending and pacing.

Falling Free

By: Lois McMaster Bujold

I really enjoy this woman’s writing. It is fast-paced and funny. It is clever and imaginative. She does characterization really well, too. I randomly read the 5th book in this series first because its called The Vor Game, so duh, had to. I thought I would circle back eventually. I invited Matt to start reading the series with me and he cosigns on all of the above. This series does not ask as much of you philosophically as Dune. It does not hold your heart in its hand like Red Rising. It does not get into the mathematics of things like The Three Body Problem. But its unique with fun characters who are not your typical heroes. Highly enjoyable. Caveat: this book doesn’t fit into the series in a neat and tidy way. I am still waiting to see when it does. Supposedly it does…I guess we’ll see.

A Little History of Economics

By: Niall Kishtainy

This was everything I hoped it would be. It was informative and not boring. The narration was great and for a subject-matter book was perfectly easy to follow in audio format. My take-away is that I think we need a new theory of economics that takes into account people’s (individual and societal) time and the quality of their environment to calculate a true economic status. I was also reinforced in my belief that most economists, while probably well-meaning can really fuck off with this pseudo-science bullshit. If you’re going to make shit up, maybe try looking beyond the material. I wanted an overview and an interesting read to compliment some of the heavier reading I’ve done on the subject such as Road to Serfdom. For that, this book was wonderful. Nothing against the book, I just think most of this field of research is so terribly subjective that it’s absurd.

Five Children and It

By: E. Nesbitt

For Victorian-era children’s literature this was quite good. Compared to more contemporary authors, not so much. But giving credit where credit is due, this is a very imaginative and fun story that Vor was able to follow and enjoy despite the more antiquated language-structure. Taking a moment for broader reflection, I think it’s interesting how language has changed and how it requires a concerted effort on the part of younger readers to invest into classic literature. I’m thinking to myself as we are listening: “Vor doesn’t know wtf thou means.” We have run into this language disconnect several times now. The first time was with Beatrix Potter but I thought the content of those books was weird and have passed on the rest of her repertoire. Vor and I both enjoyed The Secret Garden, The Wizard of Oz, The Princess and the Goblins, and to some extent The Golden Goblet - all of which are written in a more formal, dated version of English. FCandIt was above the threshold of enjoyment as well. As a parent, be ready to patiently explain if you’re reading this with a kiddo.

Shards of Honor

By: Lois McMaster Bujold

Another fun read by Bujold. I loved getting to know the world through this love story. Love story? Yes. But not sappy, stupid shit. In this context the love story is a fun narrative device and ultimately is just a background thread tying the other events of the book together. As mentioned above, if you are expecting any continuity between Falling Free and SOH, you will be frustrated. Consider the context of FF as informative of the larger galactic context in SOH and leave it at that. Cordelia, Arol, Bothari, etc are all interesting characters unto themselves and interact in a way that left me feeling that the psychology of the characters was consistently considered when placing them in inter-relational situations. Well done.

The Practicing Stoic

By: Ward Farnsworth

I liked the book more as it progressed but, overall, would be curious to see if there is a better overview of Stoicism out there.

The good:

The Stoic principles are great. So, if you are a true beginner to the subject, you’ll probably get a lot out of this.

The organizational structure is really well done for what Farnsworth is attempting. The practicality and nuance of the subject-matter blooms the longer your keep reading but could indeed be taken piece-meal if one so chose.

The bad:

The organizational structure. This is a very personal preference, but I would have liked to experience the propositions in context. I would not have known that ahead of time, though.

TPS was not at all a bad book. You might like it way more than me. It didn’t light me up and ultimately, I have been a practicing Stoic for many years due to my personal integration/amalgamation of many spiritual practices. So at the end of the day, I wasn’t blown away with the book or topic but that doesn’t mean you won’t be.

Foundation

By: Isaac Asimov

Better the second time around. I listened to this book about 3 years ago. My take away then was: men talking stressfully at each other. Now, everyone is going batshit about the series on iTune. Since the positive reception of the show and my take-away didn’t fully line up, I was starting to think I was losing my edge or perhaps that my listening skills were not fully developed at the time I initially read the book. But, no. I was right. This book is like 90% dialog. The difference in my reception this time is in the knowing. I was familiar with the ideas the book was attempting to convey and that was helpful. Secondarily, I am way more familiar with early Sci-Fi as a genre and its nuances and short-comings. See more on that below. All in all, I liked the ideas much better this time because I wasn’t waiting for there to be action and could just sink my teeth into the dialog. Spoiler alert - there is no action. If you want a version of the story with action, definitely just watch it.

Netherwings

By Django Wexler

Well, shit. This was a good story. It was a middle-grade story but it was good enough to have me fully invested after about the 3rd chapter. Middle-grade books are really doing it for both Vor and me lately. They are dramatic enough with ample action and suspense to keep me invested while being just predictable enough that I’m not worried about sex and gore and major psychological trauma for Vor. For Vor they also hit a sweet spot. He’s not a baby so kid’s books are often too babyish for him but on the flip side, when it comes to hard copies, he could not actually read read these books yet. But that doesn’t mean he is not ready for the content. He is. So audiobooks work well for him to engage with stories that are at his maturity level if not his “reading” level. I’m really excited for him to gain mastery of reading text so he can start to choose books on his own from the library at school. In the mean time, he continues to surprise me with insightful and penetrating questions for books on this level that show me he is, very much, paying attention to relatively complex narrative structure and drama despite the medium. I hope we get more from this author in this dimension asap.

Barryar

By Lois McMaster Bujold

I am pretty well won over at this point and am a full-fledged fan of Bujold’s writing. The first half of this book is a little slower. The second half is a full court press. If you have read any of her other books, Barryar holds true to her witty/sardonic, character-forward approach. Cordelia and Bothari shine and the set-up for Miles to enter the scene is perfect. Highest Barryaran marks!

The Unfettered Mind

By: Takuan Soho

Not suspending disbelief or applying a critical mind - kinda stodgy. The metaphors were poetic but rigid. This was a very restrained work. Now, if we apply some perspective to the content, that same observation turns from critique to praise. I think restrained would be a compliment for the intersection of Zen and Swordsmanship! It’s a beautiful work and the narrator has a buttery baritone voice that is naturally suited for this gorgeously formal writing style. The question of whether or not you will like this book is likely going to boil down to whether or not you have enough historical basis to place the piece culturally. And, from there, whether you have an interest in Zen or Swordsmanship.

The Einstein Intersection

By: Samuel R. Delany

Good vintage Sci-Fi. To me, that means it was kinda weird, a little obscure, had enough detail to give you a sense of what was going on but left quite a bit up to the imagination. I wouldn’t want the same from more modern works. I’m learning to take the early stuff as a sub-genre and appreciate them in that context. This is probably one of my reading take-aways for 2021 as a whole.

April book drop

Screen Shot 2021-05-06 at 2.19.17 PM.png

The Kingdom of Copper

By: SA Chakraborty

Wow. The last quarter of the book is teeeeeeense. And there is no resolution. It ends in the middle of a huge cliff. Thankfully, I was able to go right on to the next one. As middle books in a trilogy goes, this was well done. Enough happened to feel like the action warranted dividing into three parts - this is being written from the perspective of having also finished the third book just a few weeks later. I’ll expand my review of the series in that break-down.

Screen Shot 2021-05-06 at 2.17.11 PM.png

Tales of Beatrix Potter

By: Beatrix Potter

I find it a little off-putting to anthropomorphize animals and then to have them eating each other. For that reason these stories never really sit well with me. It feels like low-key cannibalism. For such well-beloved children’s stories I found them really rather grotesque. Just me? Vor seemed to enjoy them. Maybe there just weren’t that many books/children’s books back in the day and that is how this book gained such reknown but I didn’t find them endearing or loveable or really at all valuable in terms of teaching lessons even. Pass.

Note: The works in this book are presented in a lot of other books with similar names. This is the exact version I read.

Screen Shot 2021-05-06 at 2.14.54 PM.png

Goodbye, Things

By: Fumio Sasaki

I really loved it. I’ve been minimal for years yet I still found this book both inspiring and useful. An ironic note, the list of tips for going minimal is NOT a minimal list.

Screen Shot 2021-05-06 at 2.13.28 PM.png

The Goose Girl

By: Shannon Hale

I started listening to this with Vor and it was clear there was an impending dark turn. He wasn’t fully into the story anyway, so we paused and I finished on my own. My intuition was correct, there is a dark turn. It was not as insidious as I had feared, however. In the end this has a big character arc for the heroine and feels like a good read for the tween group. There are sequels. I probably will end up reading them eventually.

Screen Shot 2021-05-06 at 2.10.30 PM.png

Peter Pan

By: JM Barrie

This was an Audible Original adaptation. It was very engaging for Vor but a far cry from staying true to canon. I feel like the title is misleading and should have been billed as being “based-on.” You know the story of Peter Pan. No need to elaborate.

Screen Shot 2021-05-06 at 2.01.25 PM.png

Coyote America

By: Dan Flores

An unexpectedly interesting book. There was a depth and nuance to the information offered so that I never felt bored despite the deep dive into a specific subject matter. Narrative works well as a literary device to help the reader/listener stay invested in the overall arc of the book. Another free offering for Audible subscribers.

Screen Shot 2021-05-06 at 1.59.25 PM.png

For White Folks Who Teach In The Hood…and the Rest of Y’all Too

By Christopher Emdin

Damn. This book delivered. I think one of the biggest pitfalls of the social justice genre is that they are essentially self-help books for white people. It gets pretty repetitive. Especially, if you have read Bell Hooks, Angela Davis, James Baldwin, etc etc to whom newcomers writing in this genre often can’t hold a candle. Their contributions are welcome but often come off as basic for people who have been invested in “doing the work,” for a long time. This however, phew. Is it narrative? Yes. Is it pointed? Yes. Is it also broadly applicable? Yup! Not only is this a critique of and solutions for white teachers entering into POC spaces, it is a brutal commentary on the epic failings of our education system. BUT! The thing is solutions exist. They are also deftly laid out in this book. Highly recommend.

Screen Shot 2021-05-06 at 1.57.40 PM.png

What I Talk About When I Talk About Running

By: Haruki Murakami

How does he do it? How did he write a book about a hobby/sport I have next to no interest/involvement in and make it interesting? He has a way about examining the minutae that gives his writing a perpetually fresh, familiar feeling. I just finished another Murakami book and it was no less detailed about no less mundane things yet it was still engrossing. This book is not quite so standard in the author’s style in that, there is always some central crux-point for his narrative works. And around that point Murakami weaves exquisite insights into mundanity/the human experience. Here its just - running. Running and life. Life and Running. A beautiful meander through the mind of a truly gifted writer and apparent multi-sport athlete. I Stan.

Screen Shot 2021-05-06 at 1.56.09 PM.png

Midsummer’s Mayhem

By: Rajani LaRocca

The woman POC author I was looking for when I was duped by SA Chakraborty. JK, kinda. This was GREAT! I chose this book as a Mama-Vor book and it didn’t disappoint. The constant calls to A Midsummer Night’s Dream are of course lost on a 5-year-old but as I was hoping, the story was alive and substantive without any Shakespearian background. There’s magic, fae and BAKING! The author clearly knows her stuff. I think I can safely say, if you enjoy The Great British Baking Show you will enjoy this book. There are even recipes at the end! I enjoyed every bit of this scrumptious story (read it to get the inside joke).

Screen Shot 2021-05-06 at 1.53.56 PM.png

Who We Are and How We Got Here

By: David Reich

A book about genetics. I found the first part of this book SOOOO boring. There was a lot of science info unanchored by meaningful real-world discussion or narrative. I think that was its failing. I was not in the right mindset to take it all in. Its one of those books I wish I had a hard copy of and would read slowly making annotations on the side. But in all honesty, I doubt I would have had the patience to make it to the last third. The last third of this book was great. It was everything it promised to be and didn’t deliver on in the first 2/3. The last bit of the book really dives into the current sociological and philosophical war that is going on in the field of genetics. I will let the author speak for himself on this as I found his writing to be profound.

“It is now undeniable that there are non-trivial average genetic differences across populations in multiple traits and the “race” vocabulary is too ill defined and too loaded with historical baggage to be helpful. If we continue to use it, we will not be able to escape the current debate which is mired in an argument between two indefensible positions. On the one side, there are beliefs about the nature of the differences that are grounded in bigotry and have little basis in reality. On the other side, there is the idea that any biological differences between populations are so modest that, as a matter of social policy, they can be ignored and papered over. It is time to move on from this paralyzing false dichotomy and to figure out what the genome is actually telling us.”

I’m impressed with Reich’s boldness and willingness to put himself in an unwinnable position. He is making friends on neither side of the aisle here and instead seems to really hold his idealistic ground. I find that admirable and impressive. Aside from the style/pacing of the book, my other critique is that author somewhat minces words on the topic of male genetic dominance. when one society takes over another men sexually assault and rape women, a fact that is never stated forthcomingly. I found that he was being realistic but way too kind in the way he was painting the picture.

Screen Shot 2021-05-06 at 1.49.44 PM.png

The Empire of Gold

By: SA Chakraborty

SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS

Ok, now that is out of the way. This is your last chance. I’m going in and I’m not holding back. You were warned.

GAAAAH. They did Dara so dirty!!! There is a little redemption for him at the end but the whole time I was just gritting my teeth at Ali and Nahri’s hypocrisy. Did Ali grow on me? Yes. Did I overall really like Nahri? Yes. But they still both pissed me TF off. Dara is hands down a tragic figure for the ages. By the way, I’m not structuring my thoughts on this trilogy because most of it is just me emoting and there’s no reason behind it.

Jamshid and Muntadir! Love. Would have really liked to have more Zaynb in the series. She was amazing. Queen Hatset also amazing. Sobek - such a cool concept. End of the day I want so much more from this world. I want to follow Dara to the ends of the Earth. I want to circle back to Ali and Nahri’s descendants and see how they interface with Dara and the slave rings. I want to know more about the Peri. There’s endless material here.

Surprises that made me happy: Nahri’s grandpa. I straight up did not see that coming. It was a great way to end on a positive note where so much else was tinged with sadness. Speaking of - Dara riding off into the sunset to gather slave rings and free the enslaved Djinn. It was the mature thing to do and so I begrudging accept it. Did I want he and Nahri to end up together? 100,000%. But in all honesty, they are both damaged goods and their love, though real, was also a tangle of trauma bonds. And he needed to go heal and she didn’t need to save him. Its a RuPaul moment. If Dara can’t love himself…

Final thoughts. Still angry the author is white. It means some POC writer somewhere who also could have written and published this story was displaced. I’m obsessed with this world and excited to see it come to screen on Netflix. There is SOOOO much room to cast this with actors who cover a wide range of skin tones and ethnicities. I’m am hoping desperately that they don’t white-wash everyone. Ugh. pleeeeease let them get it right!! I want more books. I would love to see Chakraborty team up with an actual author of color to flesh out some of the stories that are begging to be told. Overall I fell in love with this trilogy. And was happy to spend the 60+ hours of listening to see it through to the end.